Saturday, February 14, 2026

Why Fear is Good (Landscapes of Fear, part 2)

This is part 2 of a series on landscapes of fear (Part 1, Part 3): today I am going to talk about why it’s important to build a landscape that evokes fear. But before I get to that, one announcement:

– This is not sponsored and is entirely unasked for: Tales from the Tape Deck is launching soon on Kickstarter.  It’s a “tabletop role-playing game that fits in a cassette tape case. Each Volume contains a new setting, character options and rules.”  Today’s post is partly about why you should check it out.

 Landscapes of Fear: Why Fear?

 "...love is held by a chain of obligation which, men being selfish, is broken whenever it serves their purpose; but fear is maintained by a dread of punishment which never fails."

    --Niccolo Machiavelli, The Prince (1513) (trans. by Luigi Ricci)

Artwork © Nicolas Samori.


Before I dive into the various tricks I use to make my PCs afraid as often as I can, I want to pause and talk motivation.  I am still learning how to be a good GM, and I struggled with this post this week.  I had to pull the reasoning for my current playstyle out of my gut, and examine it in the light of day.  At the end, much of what I have to say is standard OSR advice for GMs, just hopefully reframed and connected in a useful way.  


So, why make your players afraid? 


If you are playing Mothership, this isn’t even a question–fear is a game goal.  So first, some context: my weekly game is DnD 5e in an OSR style: it’s not horror or even grimdark (we are not into hurt kids or adult themes, its seven dads drinking beer and being heroic).  Despite that, I consider making my players afraid very important, for one simple reason.


I had to go look up the psychological term for what I am about to say, and it’s not going to be a surprise to any veteran GM out there: “emotional arousal” (engagement).  When we feel one emotion strongly, our physiological response causes all emotions to hit harder.  Our attention narrows, our heart speeds up. Joy feels bigger, anger feels sharper, sadness feels heavier.  And most importantly, when we are emotionally aroused, our memories are more vivid.  


That’s what I want our game to be: memorable, emotional, fun.  Full of narrow escapes and hard choices, excitement and sweet victories.  


Emotions lie at the heart of storytelling: we feel emotional resonance to a good story or to a friend’s fate.  An echo of their reaction, kindled in our hearts.  Emotional engagement is central to both the sandbox and railroad styles of GMing: regardless of whether the GM wants emotion to emerge organically, as a result of players making meaningful choices (sandbox), or they want to tell a story that leads players into emotion (railroad), their goal is an emotional reaction.  GMs want players to be excited and having fun, to tell stories later about their session.


A good GM lays the groundwork for their players to feel emotional resonance: they create a landscape of emotion. There are lots of emotions a GM can draw upon: Anger, Disgust, Fear, Joy, Surprise, Wonder, Sadness, Contempt, Trust, Anticipation, Pride, Embarrassment, etc.  Sly Flourish is an advocate for evoking wonder through fantastic places, for example.  


A good session should cause a diversity of feelings, with positive emotions hopefully dominating.  If a session feels flat, with inattentive players (been there)--they are not emotionally engaged in the outcome.  This may be because they feel they have no agency in driving the story, no attachment to the story of the world or of their character, or many other things.  Pulling on their emotions pulls them back into the game–they will want to meaningfully respond to what happened.  If the GM gives them agency to do so, they have achieved a virtuous cycle of Emotionally Engaged GamingTM (see my gorgeous diagram below).  


So why focus on evoking fear, amongst all the emotions? 


Because, to quote a great blog post, adventure RPGs are “emotional gambling.” Players can’t help but invest emotions, to a greater or lesser degree, in the PCs they role-play: creativity, pride, affection, empathy, joy.  Our player characters are small extensions of our identity.  When these fingers of our self are threatened with death or harm, however fictional or remote, we feel the stirrings of fear.  


By risking loss or harm to our character, we gamble our emotional state.  The return is emotional engagement, and more intense joy when they survive and we win.


It’s no surprise then that many fantasy RPGs, 5e included, have conflict as a big part of the core rules and play culture. Combat, by indirectly striking at a player’s mental well-being, creates fear and emotional engagement.  If one can ‘win’ the game of DnD, if at all, it’s by not dying in combat.  To quote Jared Sinclair’s excellent blog post on win conditions in role-playing games: 


“One can be said to win combat if one makes it out alive: "One ought not to die," then. A loss condition is as good as a win condition for instantiating a value system in a game. We could go further, and observe that these parts of tabletop role-play where an implicit win condition pops up (such as "one ought not to die") are also the places where the rules take on a shape more akin to board games or video games.


Even disconnected players value not dying, because dying feels like losing, like punishment.  In other words, fear of character death and diminishment is a shortcut to getting your players to care about playing the game. 



Triggers of fear: you have to be willing to kill your darlings

"...the name was the important thing for inspiring the necessary fear."

    --The Princess Bride (1987)

Nothing I wrote above is a surprise to OSR players: they have long maintained the importance of having a real possibility of character death, it gives the game stakes (i.e., emotional engagement).  We have to address the serious challenge of a lack of player risk in many adventure games (and especially 5e), and the downsides of death in OSR games–I am going to talk about that in part 3.  But, before I end this post, I think we can learn something by examining this framing a step further.  

Common GM advice is to engage players by using all the senses when describing a scene.  Emotional engagement often occurs via a trigger, appearing through one of the senses.  Thus, it’s important to involve all the senses not only when giving room descriptions, but also when designing a RPG session or a RPG game.  Touch, for example, is one of the reasons I think Mausritter is so popular–consider the visceral emotional trigger of physically accepting a condition card and having to pick up and remove a beloved item card to make room.  Another example: dice pools are popular, because who doesn’t like throwing a lot of dice to find out what happens?  Another: the jenga tower of Dread RPG. 

RPGs are predominantly a visual- and hearing-dominated medium.  It’s hard to conjure up taste or smells, but increasing the diversity of visual, audio, and tactile experiences can aid engagement. Music, props, bowls with dungeon dice, doom tokens, visuals, minis–yeah yeah I can feel the collective eyeroll of you readers.  We KNOW this stuff, this is why the hobby is like it is, why it starts out cheap and can snowball into half your disposable income if you let it.  A diversity of stimuli works up to a point, that point being the distraction of your players with too many stimuli (and/or the insanity of the GM trying to prep all this stuff).  As always, season to your taste.

But it helps me, at least, to finally connect all the disparate means-to-an-end (tips and tricks) suggested to me as a GM, with the ultimate goal (emotional engagement).  It encourages me to experiment for greater emotional arousal, and move beyond my personal default gaming set-up.  

What’s more, not all ‘experiences’ (or ‘cues’) translate into strong emotional triggers.  If they did, we would be so overstimulated we couldn’t function day to day.  The key to running an engaging RPG is to regularly elevate a cue into a trigger, just often enough to keep your players hooked.  Boring combat won’t do it, and combat is boring without a risk of failure.  If you want your PCs to emotionally respond to a cue, they have to believe it comes with a consequence.  

For your words and cues to matter, they have to be backed by action.  At the right time, you must follow through at least once when there is a cue–that’s what makes it an emotional trigger.  When they make a mistake and you have clearly communicated the danger, maybe they survive this time.  But at some point, you must kill your darling PCs, hurt them, curse them, ruin their day, tear down their character sheet piece by piece.  All so you can cheer them on later.  

Best to do it early, so you can train them in the ways of fear..  A cautious player, about to do something dangerous so they can be a hero, is living their best life.

I want to close this part of this series by giving two examples of successful emotional triggers in my recent games.

In this light, looking at my last session, I made a mistake.  There were ‘translator crowns’ that PCs were encouraged to put on to communicate with the denizens of a strange city: they were mind-enslavement devices, of course.  I SHOULD have gone to Burger King, gotten some paper crown props, and handed one to each PC that put them on (two did, my players rock).  Visceral touch would have increased the player’s horror at their mistake–they were plenty chagrined, but this would have brought it home.  I had crafted a solid emotional trigger of fear and horror, but no associated stimulus.

Also in this light, I now know why I had the greatest game of Pirate Borg ever when Ahmed of Suffety Games ran ‘Into the Maelstrom’ for us at PAXU26.  Without spoilers, we were on a mission to save some imprisoned friends, represented by a playing card dealt to each of us, and every time a bell rang, the GMs around us (this was a multi-table tourney) removed one of the cards as a PC’s prisoner died.  But Ahmed went one step further–he picked up the card from in front of the affected player, and ripped. it. into. pieces.  This was some top-level GM emotional impact!  It turned what was an annoying cue for other tables, the bell, into an visceral experience that made all of us wince with regret.  By doubling down on a cue, diversifying it, he turned it into an fearful emotional trigger.

It also led to absolute hilarity when we later found a random Relic and Ahmed rolled…a resurrection stone.  Every time we used it, I kid you not, he went through the pile of ripped cards, trying to find a fragment of each prisoner to return to us.  The next day he was in the main hall, a fragment of each of our cards in his pocket: just in case he ran into us, he wanted us to have a souvenir.  

Best. GM. Ever.  Ahmed clearly knows the value of visceral emotional triggers in creating emotional engagement.  

Not coincidentally, he’s designed a new role-playing game that is literally set to a cue, music–Tales of the Tape Deck.  Talk about setting the mood–I imagine emotional triggers galore, the music pounding out and coinciding with dramatic events.  If this sounds like something you would like, Ahmed has no idea I am pitching the game here, I am just a random player he had at a con.  Go surprise him with a Kickstarter follow!  If you tell him it’s because of Velocitree, he will be bewildered.



Now, during this post, you might have been thinking this all sounds too pat, too easy.  How do you kill characters in 5e without going emotionally broke and losing players (I’d call this a ‘bust’ in emotional gambling, when you wager and lose)?  Conversely, how do you get OSR players to even care enough about their low-level characters to flinch (I’d call this ‘playing slots’ in emotional gambling, not willing to wager big)?  I’ll get to that in Part 3, when I talk about how I and other GMs build landscapes of fear around players.  


______

Want to read more? This is an accidental series on building landscapes of fear around players in adventure games, which is distinct from fear in horror games.  

Part 1: Fear of monsters is central to society. If NPCs fear, the players will too. 

Part 2 (this post): Fear is an easy shortcut to player engagement.

Part 3: The first step to fear: making PCs care about failing.  OSR and traditional RPG play cultures often fall short at this task.

Part 4: Make them feel threatened, without stealing agency: foreshadow danger and foreground dangerous choices. 

Part 5: Tempt them, surprise them, spiral events out of their control.

Part 6: Allow them to fail, and to survive to succeed one day.


Before I go:

–My first RPG zine, Shadowfeats: OSR Feats and Quirks for Shadowdark, is out now! 130 even-level Feats. 135 Quirks. Grounded options for Shadowdark that give characters texture and teeth. May your PCs be unique before they die.




Sunday, February 8, 2026

Landscapes of Fear, part 1: Fear and Society

Inspired by two excellent posts on using ecology to make encounters more realistic and exciting (Writing Encounters in Networks and Trophic Encounters), I started reflecting on how I use ecology in my weekly game.  I realized I use it in two main ways: to create a sense of verisimilitude, and to create fear.  Realism seems self-evident and the folks over in r/worldbuilding (and linked above) have that covered. In this first post, I am going to describe how I use the ecology of fear to world-build.  In my second post, I am going to describe how I use it to make my PCs very, very afraid.

The Behavorial Ecology of Fear
I have been reading the Hobbit to my son, and I was struck by the quiet menace of the Desolation of Smaug.  Few birds, sparse grass, no trees: the dragon poisoned the rich land of Dale and drove away so many birds that they flooded in after his death.  

And you know what?  Tolkien anticipated an amazing ecological effect that was discovered in the 1990s when wolves were re-introduced to Yellowstone: the Landscape of Fear.  The few dozen wolves had an outsize impact on elk and bison, keeping them constantly looking and running, eating less and dying in winter from low fat reserves.  As a result of less elk browsing, the whole ecosystem changed: aspen and willow appeared along rivers, beaver came back, and tree-loving songbirds returned as well.  Just like when Smaug died.


When you read the DnD 5e monster manual, they talk a bit about the effects on the surrounding landscape of lairs of dragons and other powerful creatures.  After all, DnD and many modern fantasy RPGs are built on the bones of Tolkien.  But looking at the maps of the various fantasy worlds and settings, I just feel like most don't take creating landscapes of fear far enough (Dark Sun excepted, as always).  They really should be asking: 

1) How does fear of monsters fundamentally change the world?  

2) How can we cause PCs to fear monsters?  

Macro-scale: Building a world full of fear
Animals live in worlds bounded by fear: songbirds get picked off by hawks, deer fear wolves, and fish huddle in constant vigilance for sharks.  Human societies that are close to nature often share this vigilance and/or fear. The forest was a dangerous place in medieval Europe, full of bears and wolves and bandits, and the Grimm fairy tales reflect that peasant distrust of forests.  The forest remains a dangerous place for modern poor farmers in India and Nepal, with tigers and leopards attacking villagers and boars and monkeys stealing out to raid fields.  

It's hard to argue that medieval population densities would be achieved by a society exposed to constant monster attacks.  Even if magic and fighting ability were prevalent, food is produced by those skilled in its production: they don't have time to also learn fighting or magic.  Not and maximize production like medieval peasants did!  

So instead, they would constantly watch, fight, and maybe flee, like elk interacting with wolves, and food production would fall, and population density will be lower.  One Bullette could destroy most of Normandy before heroes ever arrived on the scene. And in a frontier, it's likely that every surviving adult would be have some experience as a fighter, making low-level PCs less 'unique heroes', more 'fools that want money'.  

Settings that are Points of Light, where cities and towns are small and widely spaced, take this lesson to heart.  If we want to have high population densities in a setting, the monster problem has to have been locally solved.  And honestly?  I don't love Points of Light settings--I want more towns, more politics, more international plots and evil organizations...and yeah, more stuff.  AND I want lots of monsters.  Monsters could be rare, yeah, but where's the fun in that?

So what is keeping the monsters at bay?  
That's one central question of fantasy world-building.  Here are d8 answers I like to use in my settings, with landscapes of fear everywhere:

1--They don't keep them at bay.  Instead folk live in harmony with the spirits/monsters of the world, through sacrifice, rituals, folklore, knowledge of monster behavior and ecology, and adapted societies.  A monster is just an angry spirit, and most spirits can be propitiated.  If you want to cross the Deep, you need the right magic to pass the Kraken without notice.  The goblins do not touch villages surrounded by a ring of bloodweed.  This take works especially well when the PCs are travelers, ignorant of the local customs and ecology.  

2--Walls make good neighbors.  Be they of hewed stone, natural mountains or stormy oceans, or of magic (or all three), one side protects civilization, the other is the Wild.  The degree to which these walls are effective barriers affects the contrast.  The elves raised a line of fairy-mounds to keep out aberrations that hunt them.  Sea monsters never enter shallow shore waters--no one knows why.  The desert Wall keeps the titanic radioactive worm Utu-Hagal from us.  This approach allows you to place civilization in close proximity to a wilderness filled with monsters.

3--Distance is the trick.  The worst monsters are far away, legends that come raiding once a generation at most.  Around their homes are broken landscapes riddled with object demonstrations of their power.  Societies near monsters are warped by fear of them, building towns on lakes (humans near Smaug) or hiding in caverns (elves near Smaug).  Only a fool beards monsters in their lairs. Many of the worst monsters are dormant in this approach, and if the PCs fail in their quest, they doom whole regions.  

4--Constant war.  Every child is training to fight the monsters, and society is organized around driving them back.  Learning the patterns and behavior of monsters is critical for survival. Kobold raids come once a year with the first full moon of spring, and the walled villages are ready to meet them.  The coastal towns use alchemical fire to push the barbarians and their fanged steeds beyond the Great Road. Colonizers of the great jungle live in massive forts, every hand ready to hold back the native's zombie hordes.  I don't do this everywhere in my worlds, but a region at constant war is a great recipe for tension, for quests, and for making the heroes wonder who the real bad guys are.

5--The Gods.  This is why the people pray to anything and everything that can protect them from the dark and the fangs.  They raise up gods, godlings, minor spirits, anything that can get the job done.  When that fails, they worship the strongest monster to keep the others away.  The city of Eversink is the body of the goddess Denari, who protects her citizens from the angry Marshes next door.  Each village in the western frontier worships a spirit, a demi-godling whose job it is to patrol and keep them safe at night.  If we want PCs to engage with gods and strange religions, what better way than making it personal?  Gods can't be everywhere, and even a powerful god can need help driving back the dark.  And if you go with many, many gods and godlings, there is no canon to track, and none of them are perfect or all-powerful.  Evil (or self-interested) quest-givers abound!

6--The Worst are Locked Away.  Similar to the Walls and Distance, but requiring neither.  The monsters flourish in another world, adjacent to our own.  The reason civilization has risen again is that forgotten armies of aberrations have been locked behind Portals, waiting for a chance to invade.  The worst godlings, the ones that turn on their people, become locked in their temples, sinking into the earth.  Dungeons and the underworld are cursed prisons built by the ancients, containing the monsters they could not kill.  This is a fun premise if you want the monsters to be right there, just beyond daily life.

7--Evil defeats itself.  This is the main premise of Krynn, a DnD setting, and assumes that monsters are more interested in attacking each other (or weak/disorganized relative to humanity).  The water grubs of the deep desert are focused on assailing their kin.  The dragons of the far mountains rarely leave, or their lairs will be bespoilt by rivals.  The orc tribes only unite once every ten generations.  I feel like this is the default explanation in many traditional RPG settings: there's nothing wrong with it, just feels over-used and too broadly applied.  You really think the hobgoblins couldn't win?  Order of the Stick would like a word.

8--Humans are a sometimes food.  The funniest and most creative responses to this post I have seen so far (from my colleague Jay(189birds) and a creative Redditor who I hope will let me cite them here one day), is that humans and other sentients just are not nutritious enough for monster populations to grow and/or keep eating past a proverbial late-night raid on the fridge for ice cream.  Or that humans and our allies smell bad, and our pollution and stink keeps monsters at bay.  Regardless, something about us is off, and that keeps the monsters in check.  This premise is a great one, especially because it points to a world in which humans and their allies could live in harmony with monsters, but are not for various reasons.  Maybe we need them for alchemical products, like Bennett's novel 'The Tainted Cup', and we keep angering the monsters?  Maybe our stink waxes and wanes over time?

If you have more ways you world-build and keep monsters at bay (or not), I'd love to hear them in the comments.  My current game, for reasons of prep-time and personal preference, is a pastiche of different settings and modules.  There, I use most of the examples above. Every society is different, and what some societies consider a monster, others consider citizens (e.g., orcs).  But all the societies are vigilant against monsters, and the PCs learn from the locals what monsters to fear...often after the fact.  This is 5e after all, and super-heroic they feel until it all goes wrong.

The PCs are adventuring into different regions, ignorant of the local approaches to monsters or the history.  They are learning these answers about monsters at their cost (so far for my weekly campaign: one shipwreck, one tsunami, a month of Geas servitude after they released a monster and destroyed a city block, one plague of mimics, and Gates just waiting to be opened...).  I tell them nothing, and they get adventure, fearful escapes, and mysteries they are just starting to fathom.  

So, the heroes start out cautious because the locals are afraid or reverent, and then, as GM, I teach them to fear the landscape of monsters (running away makes winning all the sweeter). How, exactly, and why?  That is the subject for Part 2 of this post.  

______

Want to read more? This is an accidental series on building landscapes of fear around players in adventure games, which is distinct from fear in horror games.  

Part 1 (this post): Fear of monsters is central to society. If NPCs fear, the players will too. 

Part 2: Fear is an easy shortcut to player engagement.

Part 3: The first step to fear: making PCs care about failing.  OSR and traditional RPG play cultures often fall short at this task.

Part 4: Make them feel threatened, without stealing agency: foreshadow danger and foreground dangerous choices. 

Part 5: Tempt them, surprise them, spiral events out of their control.

Part 6: Allow them to fail, and to survive to succeed one day.

Thursday, January 29, 2026

Hungry is the Dark: Reaction Draws as Alarm Dice

I was going to bed last night when my friend Dadstep sent me the coolest idea, why not do opposed overloaded reaction rolls with cards, instead?  He calls it the overloaded reaction draw, it's wonderful, go read about it now, I will wait.  

Okay you back?  Because I want to share some card ideas arising from that fun conversation and his genius blogpost.  And if you don't think cards are cool in RPGs, I include a neat dice alternative at the very end, scroll down.


Cards are neat--suits are basically d13s, and you can convert them to d12s by removing the Kings.  Ace low, Queen high (Dadstep prefers the d13--which I think is neat and am going to playtest. An Oracle in the middle?!).  


But with a 12-card-per-suit system, Dadstep saw that, when you draw two cards from a shuffled deck and compare their color and rank (number), you have the exact same 2d12 Love-Anger reaction roll odds!  Here's his system in a nutshell:

A) Draw two red cards, that's good.  High is Love, Low is Anger. 

B) Draw one red and one black, Red is Love, Black is Anger.

C) Draw two black cards, that's bad.  High is Anger, Low is Love.

Easy peasy!  But that simple system opens up three cool variations on the opposed reaction 'roll': Hitting, Hands, and a Dungeon Deck.

Hitting

In my original post, I suggested players get a +3 to the Love and/or Anger roll if they do a good job negotiating, moving the monster's reaction over a bit.  With cards, to give players a reward for good negotiation, you could instead deal a third card to pick two from, like Monster Texas Hold 'Em.  So if we have 9 Anger (Black) and 7 Love (Black), then PCs parley and GM deals 4 Red, the players can pick 7 Anger (Black) and 4 Love (Red), a bit better.  This *might* be too generous on occasion, but it sounds fun to play!

Hands

You could deal out a hand of five reaction cards to the players at the start of the session, and then let them replace a drawn reaction card via good negotiation (with one of their cards). If they run out, deal them more, shuffle their discards in. Let them discard at will, but their hand size is permanently reduced. Best use for a 12 Anger is to make an annoying Friend run away? Anyway, fun mini-game!

Dungeon Deck

Alarm dice (Prismatic Wasteland) and Tension Pools (Angry GM) are ways to add to your risk the longer you dally in the dungeon (and especially if you make noise). The dungeon grows more dangerous as you go in, alerting and disturbing the inhabitants.  Can we do that with cards instead of dice?  Sure thing!

Enter the Dungeon Deck. Every time the PCs meet a monster with violence or let them flee in Fear, take the black cards from that reaction draw and add them back randomly to the reaction draw deck (discard the drawn red cards, insert drawn black cards, cut the deck).  The players will see this, and when a card shows up again to cause a monster to react with Anger, they will not be pleased.  The deck grows darker over time--the sense of menace visibly grows.  

For fun, you could pull reaction draws from the deck and never shuffle, so players can see they have limited goodwill that is being expended (a real Iconoclasts vibe).  Or every time the players successfully rest (or depart the dungeon), you could shuffle the deck, putting the red cards back in. Like with the Alarm Die, dungeon diving becomes a push-your-luck experience.  

Personally, I plan to playtest a d13 Dungeon Deck ASAP with my weekly 5e group.  I fully expect them to lose their cool as those clubs and spades return to say hi in future sessions...

Exciting week, as I am near to finalizing Shadowfeats, my first RPG publication with 130 Feats and 135 Quirks for Shadowdark character customization.   If you want to be notified when it is live on DriveThruRPG, please send an email to thorn at dreamshrike dot com, subject 'Notify Me'.  

ps--
Do you need more fun card play ideas?  Check out this midnight cardstorm from Rise Up Comus.

pps--
If you love dice and want Dungeon Dice instead of a Dungeon Deck, try this: Add +1 to the Anger roll for every encounter they choose to solve with violence (if they could have negotiated and chose not to), and -1 to the Love roll for every fleeing monster. Reset on rests. The word gets around: the Monsters run out of places to hide from the party pretty quick, and put their backs against the wall!  

Friday, January 23, 2026

Overloading the reaction roll

Reaction rolls are my favorite part of OSR/NSR play.  But they have been around forever, in largely unchanged form, since the early days of DnD.  That got me thinking: can we improve on the 2d6 reaction roll?  Recently I breezily proposed twin 2d12 as an alternative, and after revision of that concept and playtesting, I am permanently switching to an overloaded opposed reaction roll.

What's a 2d6 reaction roll?

When players encounter an enemy, roll 2d6 and sum them to determine their reaction, following this table:


If you want to read more, OSR Simulacrum did a really nice overview of their history and other fine minds have weighed in their usage and importance, including Goblin Punch, Eucatastrophic, and Murkdice. While some DnD editions have used d100 or d20 tables, the use of 2d6 makes for a nice bell curve of simple possibilities, where neutral reactions are the most likely, and immediate violence (or outright friendship) is rare. 

I use (or hack reaction rolls into) in every game I run, including DnD 5e (more on that at the end), because they are fundamental in making the world feel alive. Reaction rolls allow players to conceive of the world, not as a big battlefield, but one full of dangerous and fascinating creatures to cajole, bribe, negotiate with, intimidate, run from, and occasionally fight (when there is no other option).  

Building a better mousetrap

The 2d6 reaction roll is simple and hard to improve on.  But it has two weaknesses.  First, the minor: it requires addition and memorizing specific number ranges and/or having a printed table to hand.  Second, it has big broad categories with vague guidance, so the GM is not overly informed from the basic roll on what to do with the enemy.  Is an 8 neutral?  Look it up, then ask, WWTMD (What Would The Monster Do?).  In this, the reaction roll is much like the encounter die, and would also benefit from overloading--more detailed guidance. 

One response has been to develop monster-specific reaction tables, detailing what each monster will do with a positive/negative/neutral roll.  Called Miens in Troika, I love them but they are extra work for GMs--you need to make one for every monster (or monster type), and then have to look them up.  Something more general would help.  

To address these issues, consider this simple rule change: replacing the 2d6 with an overloaded 2d12 reaction roll.   

The idea: two opposed d12 rolls

We get more numbers from a d12 than a d6, and that's information and nuance we GMs can use.  Plus, the 2d12 oppose each other, much like the Duality dice in Daggerheart, modeling the Flight-Fight-Freeze-Friend response we all have when startled.  

But the fun part of 2d12 is this: the reactions, and the odds of those reactions, closely mimic the original 2d6 reaction roll.  They are just more nuanced and overloaded.  Want to know when a kobold is cautiously interested?  Afraid and about to flee?  Confused?  The dice tell you. 

How it works

Roll a Love d12 and an Anger d12 (different colors) and compare the values.  High values on the Love die mean Empathy and Curiosity, low values mean Indifference. High values on the Anger die mean Anger, Agitation, and Discomfort, and low values mean Calm.

If Love is greater than Anger by 4 or more, a positive reaction.  If Anger is greater than Love by 4 or more, a negative reaction.  Otherwise, the monster has a neutral reaction, affected by the relative balance of Love and Anger.  

When Love and Anger tie, the monster's reaction depends on their dice value.  Tied values near 1 are indifferent and calm, but at higher tied values of Love and Anger (>6), monsters are likely to react fearfully.  

That's the main idea in a nutshell.  See this graph:

Some stunning illustration here, huh? The green shades represent dice roll combinations that are negative reactions, the red shades are positive, white and yellow are neutral--yellow represents fear.  The labeled blue-dashed boxes represent extreme, rare reactions at high and low levels of Love and Anger. 

Love is better described as an Empathy-Curiosity roll (the Monster's attitude towards others), and Anger as an Anger-Agitation-Discomfort roll (the Monster's internal state, affected by its attitude and whether it is thriving or struggling).  So if Love wins, its Empathy towards you outweighs its Agitation and/or Discomfort.  If Anger wins, its internal Anger, Agitation, and/or Discomfort (hunger, for animals) outweighs its Curiosity towards you.  

In this roll, anytime values of Love and Anger are both above 6, it indicates increasing fear (yellow in the graph above, and the adjacent semi-fearful responses). Monsters are reacting with a mixture of strong Curiosity (noticing you), deep Agitation or Discomfort (uneasy), clear Empathy (understanding your capabilities), and passionate Anger (hating your presence).  

Like the Moldvay 2d6 reaction roll, immediate attacks and immediate friendship are rare--each occurring 2.78% (1/36) of the time, in both methods.  If you roll a 11 or 12 for Anger and a 1 or 2 for Love, the monster attacks.  If you roll a 11 or 12 for Love and a 1 or 2 for Anger, you have a friend.  

Also like the original 2d6 roll, the overloaded 2d12 has positive and negative reactions less often (25% of the time), and neutral reactions more often (50%).  Although that differs slightly from the original 2d6 odds (28% positive/negative and 44% neutral), the continuous nature of the overloaded roll means the odds are fluid.  If we say Anger that is 3 greater than Love leads to a tense, borderline negative situation, negative and near-negative reactions happen 31% of the time.

Unlike the original 2d6 reaction roll, this overloaded 2d12 reaction roll tells you clearly when monsters are likely to ignore the party, or to flee or avoid them. If you roll a 1 or 2 on both dice, the monster either doesn't care about their presence or is asleep.  If you roll an 11 or 12 on both dice, it will likely flee or react unpredictably, in turmoil and fear.  

Interpreting the Balance of Love and Anger

It all depends how much Empathy/Curiosity a monster is feeling towards others, and how much internal Anger/Agitation/Discomfort.  Here's my graphical interpretation of different possible states we encounter with the dice, extrapolating from the values of each die and these simple rules:

A) A positive/negative reaction results from a large difference (>3) between Love and Anger.  Otherwise the reaction is neutral and affected by both Love and Anger, with the bigger die more important.

B) Corner values (1, 2, 11, 12) lead to extreme reactions.

C) Ties between Love and Anger at low values are indifferent to cautious.  At high die values, with both Love and Anger >6, reactions (and especially ties) are increasingly tinged by Fear.  


I broke each d12 down into four ranges (1-3 low, 4-6 medium, 7-9 high, 10-12 extreme) and labeled each with a corresponding likely reaction.  These are not fixed categories, but suggested zones in a gradient of responses. 

In actual play, the reaction is a quick judgment call from the GM, based on the relative dice values--you don't need to reference the chart. 

Example 1: Anger 9 and Love 6--Anger is high, Curiosity is medium.  A neutral reaction, barely (difference <4).  The monster definitely doesn't like the party, but wants to know about them. That means they definitely don't trust them, falling just short of hostility.  Gollum meeting Bilbo.  

Example 2: Love 8 and Anger 4--Empathy is medium-high, Agitation is low-medium.  A positive reaction (difference >4, Love high).  They are interested in interacting peacefully with the party and learning more, but feel a bit uneasy.  I interpret that as somewhat guarded interest.  Beorn on the arrival of the 13 dwarves. 

Example 3: Love 11 and Anger 9--Empathy is extreme, Agitation is high.  A neutral reaction (difference <4). They are being very careful around the party, spooked by sudden movements, highly uneasy and afraid--but interested in interacting peacefully since they well understand their strength and could like the PCs.  I interpret that as fearful respect.  Gollum and Frodo in the marshes, before the turn.

Going further: modifying the overloaded reactions

You can modify the reaction rolls for different creatures by just adding or subtracting from each die after rolling, according to that creature's nature.  If you go over 12 or under 1, stop there.

  • fraidy cat kobolds +3 Love, +3 Anger
  • The Predator(TM) -3 Love, +6 Anger
  • Friendly Allies +3 Love, -3 Anger
  • Stolid neutrals -3 Love, -3 Anger
  • Nervous friends +3 Love
  • Hungry owlbear +3 Anger

Any reaction roll is just that, a first reaction.  It's a place to start negotiations from.  So if your PCs want to engage with the monster, I suggest they can change reactions by at most one step on each axis (+/- 3).  

You can use their actions to judge which axis is affected by their efforts. Do they bribe the monster with food, or flatter them? +3 to Love.  Do they speak slowly and softly to it, or trick it into thinking they are allies? -3 to Anger.  Calming a monster affects Anger, charming it affects Love.  

Sometimes it won't be clear, so it affects both Love and Anger (really GOOD food, accompanied by soft music; an accidental insult, paired with a bribe). But no gains should be cost-free and risk-free: time, money, food, the risk of offense, and so on.  I don't use formal negotiation rules, but they are worth internalizing.  

Some final notes (EXPANDED)

If you clicked on the Murkdice link above, you saw a 2d6 table that looks a bit like the table above.  Hilarious--I first saw it today, after working on this idea for weeks. Couple issues I see.  First, rolling 2d6 on each axis makes the corners extremely unlikely (e.g., 2 and 2, an immediate fight: odds of 1/1296)--most monsters will walk by you.  Second, I don't quite understand how the axes relate to the conditions listed: I do not want to print this out and have to look at it every time I roll.  But parallel evolution indeed--someone in the comments even suggested using 2d12 instead!  

If you want to run this system in 5e, I would start with some background reading on how to use reaction rolls in play (great advice here).  Next, I don't allow a character to add their Persuasion bonus to the initial reaction roll (it messes up the odds).  Instead, start with the initial reaction roll, and let them respond to what the monster does.  If they attempt placation or negotiation (or taunting), set a DC based on their actions and words, and a successful check (Persuasion, Intimidation, etc.) moves the Love or Anger 3 in the desired direction, just like I described in the previous section.  Or, you could, you know, just a make a fair ruling based on what they do.  If they feed the owlbear the last of their rations, let them have it!


If you want to run this system in pure B/X, just double the PC Charisma bonus added to the reaction roll (2d6 to 2d12 makes good math).  To directly emulate B/X rules (to within a few % points), apply the CHA bonus to the Love roll AND subtract that CHA bonus from the Anger roll.  And because several have asked: You can try running this system with opposed exploded 2d6, but the odds for ties are inflated and there's a lot less nuance and information as a result.  

Compared to a 2d6 roll, I feel the overloaded 2d12 reaction roll is an upgrade: more informative and intuitive to use, a touch easier, and super fun.  And if you try it out, you will use more d12, which we all know has many benefits. Please comment to let me know what you think of it!

First edit: Thanks to a great discussion with u/Current_Channel_6344 on Reddit, I renamed the Hate axis above to Anger, because while I was thinking of Hate as an internal feeling, it's more properly an external response like Love.  If a Monster is struggling or in desperation or hunger, it will experience anger, agitation, and discomfort.  If it is thriving, it will be calm.  

Second edit: You can do this all with cards!  There's a banging set of ideas about how to do that over at my colleague Dadstep's blog.  Dead simple, but so many possibilities.  I am so going to blog about this next...

Sequel 1: Hungry is the Dark: Reaction Draws as Alarm Dice